Actuality Present Forged Members Charged With Operating Nationwide Telemarketing Fraud Scheme | USAO-SDNY

Audrey Strauss, the US Legal professional for the Southern District of New York, Peter C. Fitzhugh, the Particular Agent-in-Cost of the New York Subject Workplace of Homeland Safety Investigations (“HSI”), and Dermot Shea, Commissioner of the New York Metropolis Police Division (“NYPD”), introduced the unsealing of a Superseding Indictment charging JENNIFER SHAH and STUART SMITH with conspiracy to commit wire fraud in reference to telemarketing and conspiracy to commit cash laundering.  The case has been assigned to United States District Choose Sidney H. Stein.

SHAH and SMITH had been arrested earlier at this time and can be offered this afternoon in Salt Lake Metropolis federal courtroom earlier than United States Justice of the Peace Choose Dustin Pead.

Manhattan U.S. Legal professional Audrey Strauss stated:  “Jennifer Shah, who portrays herself as a rich and profitable businessperson on ‘actuality’ tv, and Stuart Smith, who’s portrayed as Shah’s ‘first assistant,’ allegedly generated and bought ‘lead lists’ of harmless people for different members of their scheme to repeatedly rip-off.  In precise actuality and as alleged, the so-called enterprise alternatives pushed on the victims by Shah, Smith, and their co-conspirators had been simply fraudulent schemes, motivated by greed, to steal victims’ cash.  Now, these defendants face time in jail for his or her alleged crimes.”

HSI Particular Agent-in-Cost Peter C. Fitzhugh stated:  “Shah and Smith flaunted their lavish life-style to the general public as a logo of their ‘success.’  In actuality, they allegedly constructed their opulent life-style on the expense of weak, usually aged, working-class individuals.  As alleged, disturbingly, Shah and Smith objectified their very actual human victims as ‘leads’ to be purchased and bought, providing their private data on the market to different members of their fraud ring.  Working with our companions on the NYPD and the US Legal professional’s Workplace, SDNY, and with the help of HSI Salt Lake Metropolis, HSI New York labored to make sure that Shah and Smith will reply for his or her alleged crimes.  Consequently, their new actuality might very effectively prove in another way than they anticipated.”

NYPD Commissioner Dermot Shea stated:  “These people allegedly focused and defrauded lots of of victims however because of the laborious work of the NYPD and our legislation enforcement companions, this unlawful scheme was dropped at an finish.  I congratulate the NYPD detectives, Homeland Safety Investigations, and the U.S. Legal professional for the Southern District of New York for his or her laborious work in bringing these individuals to justice.”

In accordance with the allegations within the Superseding Indictment[1]:

From 2012 till March 2021, JENNIFER SHAH and STUART SMITH, along with others (collectively, the “Contributors”) carried out a wide-ranging telemarketing scheme that defrauded lots of of victims (the “Victims”) all through the US, lots of whom had been over age 55, by promoting these Victims so-called “enterprise companies” in reference to the Victims’ purported on-line companies (the “Enterprise Alternative Scheme”). 

With a purpose to perpetrate the Enterprise Alternative Scheme, Contributors, together with SHAH and SMITH, engaged in a widespread, coordinated effort to site visitors in lists of potential victims, or “leads,” lots of whom had beforehand made an preliminary funding to create a web based enterprise with different Contributors within the Scheme.  Leads had been initially generated by gross sales flooring working in, amongst different locations, Arizona, Nevada, and Utah.  The house owners and operators of these gross sales flooring operated in coordination with a number of telemarketing gross sales flooring within the New York and New Jersey space, together with in Manhattan, and supplied lead lists and help in preventing Sufferer refund requests to different Contributors working these flooring.

SHAH and SMITH, amongst different issues, generated and bought results in different Contributors to be used by their telemarketing gross sales flooring with the data that the people they’d recognized as “leads” could be defrauded by the opposite Contributors.  SHAH and SMITH acquired as revenue a share of the fraudulent income per the phrases of their settlement with these Contributors.  SHAH and SMITH usually managed every side of the frauds perpetrated by different Contributors on the people they’d recognized by, amongst different issues, figuring out which “teaching” gross sales ground might purchase leads from them, choosing the downstream gross sales flooring to which the “teaching” gross sales ground was permitted to go the leads, selecting the corporations to offer “success” companies, that’s, paperwork and data purporting to display that the companies the Contributors claimed to offer to these Victims had been precise and bonafide, setting how a lot the downstream gross sales flooring might cost, and figuring out which “merchandise” every of the downstream gross sales flooring might promote. 

To perpetrate the Enterprise Alternative Scheme, sure of the Contributors bought alleged companies purporting to make the administration of Victims’ companies extra environment friendly or worthwhile, together with tax preparation or web site design companies, however that many Victims had been aged and didn’t personal a pc.  On the outset of the Enterprise Alternative Scheme, sure Contributors employed by a purported success firm despatched a given Sufferer digital or paper pamphlets or supplied so-called “teaching periods” relating to these purported on-line companies, however at no level did the defendants intend that the Victims would truly earn any of the promised return on their supposed funding, nor did the Victims truly earn any such returns. 

SHAH and SMITH undertook vital efforts to hide their roles within the Enterprise Alternative Scheme.  For instance, SHAH and SMITH, amongst different issues, integrated their enterprise entities utilizing third events’ names and instructed different Contributors to do the identical, used and directed others to make use of encrypted messaging functions to speak with different Contributors, instructed different Contributors to ship SHAH’s and SMITH’s shares of sure fraud proceeds to offshore financial institution accounts, and made quite a few money withdrawals structured to keep away from forex transaction reporting necessities.

*                      *                      *

SHAH, 47, of Park Metropolis, Utah, and SMITH, 43, of Lehi, Utah, are every charged with one depend of conspiracy to commit wire fraud in reference to telemarketing by which they victimized 10 or extra individuals over the age of 55, which carries a most sentence of 30 years, and one depend of conspiracy to commit cash laundering, which carries a most sentence of 20 years.  The utmost potential sentences on this case are prescribed by Congress and are supplied right here for informational functions solely, as any sentencing of the defendants can be decided by the choose.  

Ms. Strauss praised the excellent investigative work of HSI’s El Dorado Activity Pressure and the NYPD.  Ms. Strauss additionally thanked HSI Utah and the US Legal professional’s Workplace for the District of Utah for his or her assist and help on this investigation.   

This case is being dealt with by the Workplace’s Cash Laundering and Transnational Legal Enterprises Unit.  Assistant United States Attorneys Kiersten A. Fletcher, Benet J. Kearney, and Robert B. Sobelman are in command of the prosecution. 

Should you consider you’ve got been a sufferer of the scheme described above, together with a sufferer entitled to restitution, and also you want to present data to legislation enforcement and/or obtain discover of future developments within the case or further data, please contact Wendy Olsen-Clancy, the Sufferer Witness Coordinator at the US Legal professional’s Workplace for the Southern District of New York, at 866-874-8900 or [email protected]  You might also report it to Detective Christopher Bastos at 917-480-7167 or [email protected]

The fees contained within the Superseding Indictment are merely accusations, and the defendants are presumed harmless except and till confirmed responsible.


[1] Because the introductory phrase signifies, the whole lot of the textual content of the Superseding Indictment, and the outline of the Superseding Indictment set forth herein, represent solely allegations, and each reality described needs to be handled as an allegation.

Similar Articles



Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Most Popular

Why referrals from buddies are nonetheless key within the...

April 15, 2021 7 min learn This text was translated from our Spanish version utilizing AI applied sciences. Errors could exist attributable to this course of. Opinions...

Is procuring by livestream the following chapter of e-commerce?

On a current morning, movie star chef Matt Adlard was whipping up some sweets on Amazon Reside, which permits sellers to hawk Amazon merchandise...

Why Your Model Is not Producing Gross sales On-line...

There you're, peacefully purchasing round for the most affordable merchandise at a retail retailer.A salesman comes round and greets you with a smile. “Is...